> Is the coinbase a secret from the miners?

SatsAndSports

npub1zthq85gksjsjthv8h6rec2qeqs2mu0emrm9xknkhgw7hfl7csrnq6wxm56

hex

98dd7fed64490f3fa43bc934ed68735bc114a5112a0bc50f797b237808bdc1cc

nevent

nevent1qqsf3htla4jyjrel5saujd8ddpe4hsg555gj5z79pauhkgmcpz7urnqprpmhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuem4d36kwatvw5hx6mm9qgsp9msr6ytgfgf9mkrmapuu9qvsg9d78ua3ajntfmt580t5llvgpesht3my5

Kind-1 (TextNote)

2026-06-03T20:32:19Z

↳ 回复 事件不存在

81efe00d6665c1825f391412be39d3956f95a5259930809110d647be4a4a1325...

Is the coinbase a secret from the miners?

No, I'm not proposing that

It's just an observation that the secret key behind the coinbase output (for simplicity, I'm assuming just one coinbase output) is something that the mining pool will not want to share with the hashers, as that would allow the hashers to steal the funds

And because this secret key is secret, we can require the pool to provide a signature that the hashers can't create, and this means that the miner (not the hasher) will be the first to learn if a given block is a winning block

In general though, I think I agree with you. But if it becomes a problem, it might be difficult to get consensus to activate

原始 JSON

{
  "kind": 1,
  "id": "98dd7fed64490f3fa43bc934ed68735bc114a5112a0bc50f797b237808bdc1cc",
  "pubkey": "12ee03d11684a125dd87be879c28190415be3f3b1eca6b4ed743bd74ffd880e6",
  "created_at": 1780518739,
  "tags": [
    [
      "e",
      "caabc85390d28642a1cf47e710ec0e9faa15cf406d7ec39c35e23d903e179b05",
      "wss://nos.lol/",
      "root",
      "12ee03d11684a125dd87be879c28190415be3f3b1eca6b4ed743bd74ffd880e6"
    ],
    [
      "e",
      "81efe00d6665c1825f391412be39d3956f95a5259930809110d647be4a4a1325",
      "wss://nos.lol/",
      "reply",
      "d3052ca3e3d523b1ec80671eb1bba0517a2f522e195778dc83dd03a8d84a170e"
    ],
    [
      "p",
      "d3052ca3e3d523b1ec80671eb1bba0517a2f522e195778dc83dd03a8d84a170e"
    ]
  ],
  "content": "\u003e Is the coinbase a secret from the miners?\n\nNo, I'm not proposing that\n\nIt's just an observation that the secret key behind the coinbase output (for simplicity, I'm assuming just one coinbase output) is something that the mining pool will not want to share with the hashers, as that would allow the hashers to steal the funds\n\nAnd because this secret key is secret, we can require the pool to provide a signature that the hashers can't create, and this means that the miner (not the hasher) will be the first to learn if a given block is a winning block\n\nIn general though, I think I agree with you. But if it becomes a problem, it might be difficult to get consensus to activate",
  "sig": "a7a92bd2ca6e8a8141f72f3b27a4661e0fcb9e2b945db0f8e0994f6eb3ccf4ca51395c5499e49a8e451bc1f5b47a8abfd6694f26ed609440b2aa62f6cacd7fc9"
}